www.jpmorganmarkets.com
North America Equity Research
09 July 2019
Equity Ratings and Price Targets
Date
Date
Source: Company data, Bloomberg, J.P. Morgan estimates. n/c = no change. All prices as of 08 Jul 19.
Earnings Preview
Focus Remains on Sustainability of Parts & Services
Strength; Raise FY Estimates on Favorable Rates
Autos & Auto Parts
Rajat Gupta
AC
(1-212) 622-6382
rajat.gupta@jpmorgan.com
Ryan Brinkman
(1-212) 622-6581
ryan.j.brinkman@jpmorgan.com
Daniel J Won
(1-212) 622-3221
daniel.j.won@jpmorgan.com
J.P. Morgan Securities LLC
page 22 for analyst certification and important disclosures.
J.P. Morgan does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports. As a result, investors should be aw
the firm may have a conflict of interest that could affect th
e objectivity of this report. Investors should consider this report as only a single
factor in making their investment decision.
After better than expected 1Q19 results, where same-store gross profit growth was
+3% for the group, driven primarily by solid, +6%, Parts & Services same-store
growth, we expect focus to remain on Parts & Services as an offset to pressures on
front-end vehicle profitability. We do not expect any material changes in new
vehicle profitability trends, and expect 1Q trends to largely continue, with used
vehicle profitability potentially getting better as evident by KMX’s results. We
believe Parts & Services should see continued mid-single digit same-store gross
profit growth for the remainder of 2019 driven by a combination of both macro
and micro factors including, an increase in UIO, increasing average vehicle age,
increasing complexity of parts, which favors dealers with OEM-certified parts vs.
independent aftermarket shops, improvement in penetration of post-warranty
customers driven by greater product offerings, and digital initiatives. We also
raise our 2019/2020 estimates for US Auto franchise dealerships driven primarily
by lower floor plan expense expectations vs prior due to favorable direction of
interest rates. We believe expectations for the group are somewhat elevated after
~1,000bps of relative re-rating since the beginning of 1Q19 reports, and we
maintain our balanced view on the sector, acknowledging some of the structural
and cyclical risks with our Dec’19 PTs showing flat upside on average.
We remain selective on stock picks, with LAD our top pick given sustained top-
tier execution, best growth metrics and highest relative upside from capital
allocation though we don’t necessarily see 2Q19 as catalyst for further re-
rating given the recent run (stock now at a ~10% premium), and future stock
outperformance will be driven by relative EPS revisions which is likely to be
gradual. Neutral rated PAG now moves higher up the pecking order given
compelling valuation after the recent derating as well as recent headwinds
potentially easing in 2H19. We remain OW on GPI given improved execution
in recent quarters, potential for continued upward relative revisions, and an
attractive valuation (~15% discount on P/E). On ABG, valuation has come in
recently, and we see the setup as favorable heading into the 2Q print. We
remain UW on AN despite improved execution in 1Q19, but still sustained
below par growth metrics that does not support its premium valuation (~5%
premium). On SAH, after recent outperformance (driven primarily by EchoPark
turning profitable), we think the stock is unattractive from a valuation
perspective (~15% premium on P/E) on our estimates, particularly given
relatively less upside from capital allocation vs peers and likely below average
Parts & Services profit growth.