没有合适的资源?快使用搜索试试~ 我知道了~
战时意大利与欧盟能源转型(英).pdf
1.该资源内容由用户上传,如若侵权请联系客服进行举报
2.虚拟产品一经售出概不退款(资源遇到问题,请及时私信上传者)
2.虚拟产品一经售出概不退款(资源遇到问题,请及时私信上传者)
版权申诉
0 下载量 122 浏览量
2022-11-16
16:11:37
上传
评论
收藏 639KB PDF 举报
温馨提示
试读
22页
战时意大利与欧盟能源转型(英).pdf
资源推荐
资源详情
资源评论
© 2022 IAIIAI PAPERS 22 | 23 - SEPTEMBER 2022
ISSN 2610-9603 | ISBN 978-88-9368-262-6
Italy | European Union | Energy security | Climate change
Powering Change. Italian and EU
Energy Transition in Times of War
by Giulia Sofia Sarno and Alberto Rizzi
keywords
ABSTRACT
The war in Ukraine has severely aected the Italian – and
the wider European – energy ecosystem, forcing Rome (and
Brussels), to reduce dependence on Russian energy yet at the
same time continue the green transition. Short- and medium-
term strategies have been adopted to move away from Moscow-
supplied gas and to curb overall demand. Nevertheless,
reconciling security and sustainability objectives remains
a key challenge for the EU. In the run-up to COP27, the UN
climate conference to be held in November 2022, the long-
term sustainability of new energy deals between EU countries
and climate-vulnerable developing countries will be under
the spotlight. The aordability of energy is also a crucial
concern, prompting a wide set of European measures that
aim to contain rising prices and explore various options for
intervention in energy markets. In this regard, Italy’s actions
have been notable, both domestically, with ad hoc measures,
and at the European level.
Ministry of Foreign Affairs
and International Cooperation
2
Powering Change. Italian and EU Energy Transition in Times of War
© 2022 IAIIAI PAPERS 22 | 23 - SEPTEMBER 2022
ISSN 2610-9603 | ISBN 978-88-9368-262-6
Powering Change.
Italian and EU Energy Transition in Times of War
by Giulia Sofia Sarno and Alberto Rizzi*
Introduction
The war in Ukraine has laid bare the complex reality of EU energy governance and
its three pillars, energy security, aordability and environmental sustainability,
which have become increasingly dicult to balance. In recent years, especially
following the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement, the EU has prioritised the
sustainability component of its energy governance, as shown by the adoption of
the European Green Deal and by the prominence given to green transition within
the NextGenerationEU fund. This post-pandemic momentum for sustainability
continued until Russian tanks crossed into Ukrainian territory on 24 February
2022.
Prior to the outbreak of this conflict, the spike in gas prices in the second half of
2021 had already shifted the debate from sustainability to aordability concerns,
with rising costs rapidly becoming politicised and the social sustainability of the
green transition being questioned in several EU member states, such as Italy and
France. With the start of the war and Russia’s weaponisation of energy resources,
security and aordability concerns have become top priorities for policymakers.
In this context, where each of the three pillars has become an urgent challenge,
the question arises whether the EU can succeed in reconciling its climate
commitments with energy security concerns and whether the Ukraine war will
act as an accelerator for the unfolding of a socially just energy transition – or will
hamper it.
Natural gas, which constitutes the main transitional fuel necessary to pursue
EU climate ambitions, is the critical issue in the EU–Russia energy divorce: the
identification of alternative supplies is challenging. The EU’s gas infrastructure is
*
Giulia Sofia Sarno is Junior Researcher in the Energy, Climate and Resources Programme at the
Istituto Aari Internazionali (IAI). Alberto Rizzi has worked as a Research Assistant at the ISPI Centre
for Business Scenarios.
.
Paper produced in the framework of the project “Osservatorio IAI-ISPI sulla politica estera italiana”.
This paper has benefited from the financial support of the Policy Planning Unit of the Italian Ministry
of Foreign Aairs and International Cooperation pursuant to art. 23-bis of Presidential Decree 18/1967.
The views expressed in this report are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the
views of the IAI, ISPI or the Italian Ministry of Foreign Aairs and International Cooperation.
3
Powering Change. Italian and EU Energy Transition in Times of War
© 2022 IAIIAI PAPERS 22 | 23 - SEPTEMBER 2022
ISSN 2610-9603 | ISBN 978-88-9368-262-6
also a weak area as it is characterised by a largely mono-directional (east to west)
fixed system of pipelines, a network that is unable to transport large quantities
of liquefied natural gas (LNG) and has limited regasification capacity in most
countries.
Italy is in a particularly vulnerable position because natural gas represents 40 per
cent of its energy mix, compared with 17 per cent in France and 26 per cent in
Germany.
1
Moreover, among EU countries Italy has a long history of reliance on
Russian energy, seen in the last decade as the best alternative to lower national
production and reduced imports from North Africa (traditionally Rome’s main
supplier), following the Arab uprisings of 2011. The Italian government has been at
the forefront of the European quest for alternative suppliers, signing agreements
with several Mediterranean and African countries, and Rome has been able to
secure steady supplies of gas –both via pipeline and LNG – for the coming years.
Italy still faces a complex scenario in terms of renewables deployment and energy
aordability in the short run.
An analysis of the current Italian situation provides a clearer picture of the
opportunities and risks of the government’s strategy. The Russian invasion
of Ukraine has been significant in terms of gas prices, prompting European
countries and institutions to consider dierent measures to deal with rising
energy costs – with mixed success. At the same time, reconciling energy security
and decarbonisation objectives represents one of Italy’s biggest challenges, as the
response to the current crisis might hamper the energy transition both at home
and in key energy partner countries.
1. Looking for alternatives: The Italian struggle to decouple from
Russia
Italy holds a unique position in EU gas markets. On the one hand, it is one of the
member states that most depends on Russian gas: in 2021, it imported 29 billion
cubic metres (bcm) from Russia, which accounted for around 40 per cent of gas
imports in a country where 50 per cent of power generation is produced by gas
power plants.
2
On the other hand, Italy is better positioned to diversify away
from Russia than other EU countries. It has direct infrastructural connections
with Algeria through the Transmed pipeline (21 bcm in 2021; potential capacity
of 27 bcm), with Libya through the Greenstream pipeline (3.2 bcm in 2021; at full
capacity), with Azerbaijan through the Trans-Adriatic Pipeline (TAP, 6.8 bcm in
2021; potential capacity of 8.5 bcm with the current set-up). Italy is also linked to
the North European gas market through the Transitgas pipeline, which connects
1
ISPI DataLab, “Crisi energetica: l’Italia è diversa?”, in ISPI Focus & Fact Checking, 16 February 2022,
https://www.ispionline.it/it/node/33404.
2
Website of the Italian Ministry of Ecological Transition-Directorate General for Infrastructure and
Security: Natural Gas, https://dgsaie.mise.gov.it/gas_naturale_importazioni.php?lang=en_US.
4
Powering Change. Italian and EU Energy Transition in Times of War
© 2022 IAIIAI PAPERS 22 | 23 - SEPTEMBER 2022
ISSN 2610-9603 | ISBN 978-88-9368-262-6
the country with the German and French networks that transport gas from
Norway, the Netherlands, Denmark and the United Kingdom through Switzerland
(2.2 bcm in 2021; potential capacity of 12 bcm). In addition, Italy has three LNG
regasification terminals, one onshore (Panigaglia) and two oshore (Adriatic LNG
in Porto Levante and OLT oshore LNG Livorno), which supplied 9.8 bcm in 2021
and have a potential capacity of 16 bcm.
3
However, increasing supply from each of
these options to replace Russian gas entails challenges. Examples include growing
domestic demand and low investment levels in Algeria, political instability in Libya
and the tight global LNG market, where major exporters such as Qatar have limited
spare capacity and exports are already booked through long-term contracts.
4
In March 2022, the Italian Minister for Energy Transition, Roberto Cingolani,
outlined all the short-term and long-term options that could allow Italy to cut
its energy dependence on Russia. He announced that, following the outbreak
of the conflict, there have been diplomatic missions to producing countries,
including Qatar, Algeria, Angola and the Democratic Republic of Congo, and that
these sources could collectively provide 20 bcm per year through short-term and
medium-term solutions. Other markets have also been considered to increase LNG
supply, including Mozambique, Nigeria and Egypt, where gas is mostly managed
by Italy’s energy giant Eni, as well as the United States.
5
Cingolani also announced
that national production of gas from existing extraction sites would be increased
by 2.2 bcm to alleviate the burden of increasing costs on national enterprises
(current national production is around 4 bcm).
6
One of the short-term options is rapidly increasing the TAP’s capacity by 1.5 bcm,
yet this is conditional on increased production in Azerbaijan. Another possibility is
maximising the use of existing LNG terminals, which would provide an additional
6 bcm per year. Finally, in case of emergency, the possibility of increasing power
production from existing coal power stations (expected to be phased out in 2025)
could be considered. In June 2022, the Italian Comitato tecnico di emergenza e
monitoraggio del sistema gas naturale, an emergency technical committee tasked
with monitoring the gas system, approved the purchase of coal in preparation for
the potential implementation of this plan in light of the Russian coal embargo that
has been adopted by the EU and entered into force in August 2022.
7
3
Italian Senate, “Informativa del Ministro della transizione ecologica sui recenti ulteriori rincari del
costo dell’energia e sulle misure del Governo per contrastarne gli eetti e conseguente discussione”,
in Resoconto stenografico 414a seduta, 16 March 2022, p. 7, https://www.senato.it/service/PDF/
PDFServer/BGT/1343136.pdf.
4
Margherita Bianchi and Pier Paolo Raimondi, “Russian Energy Exports and the Conflict in Ukraine:
What Options for Italy and the EU?”, in IAI Commentaries, No. 22|13 (March 2022), https://www.iai.
it/en/node/14859.
5
Italian Parliament-Joint Committee for the Security of the Republic (COPASIR), Relazione sulle
conseguenze del conflitto tra Russia e Ucraina nell’ambito della sicurezza energetica, 27 April 2022,
p. 4-6, https://www.senato.it/service/PDF/PDFServer/BGT/1348494.pdf.
6
Italian Senate, “Informativa del Ministro della transizione ecologica…”, cit., p. 13; Italian Parliament-
COPASIR, Relazione sulle conseguenze del conflitto tra Russia e Ucraina…, cit., p. 4.
7
“Gas, MITE: non necessario livello di allerta. Via ad acquisti carbone”, in La Stampa, 21 June 2022,
5
Powering Change. Italian and EU Energy Transition in Times of War
© 2022 IAIIAI PAPERS 22 | 23 - SEPTEMBER 2022
ISSN 2610-9603 | ISBN 978-88-9368-262-6
As for long-term measures, the government is considering the possibility of
doubling the TAP pipeline capacity through infrastructural interventions in
Albania and Greece, which would take between forty-five and sixty-five months
and would provide a total supply of 20 bcm per year. Increasing supply through new
oshore and onshore regasification terminals is another option. Renting oshore
floating terminals is a quicker and more flexible solution, requiring twelve to
sixteen months, and would lead to 16 to 24 bcm of total supply. Increasing imports
through onshore LNG regasification would entail more complex infrastructural
interventions, requiring from thirty-six to forty-eight months for implementation
and providing an estimated additional supply of 20 bcm per year.
8
Finally, Italy
has shown interest in gas reserves in the Eastern Mediterranean, with ongoing
discussions, for instance with Egypt and Israel, to increase supplies through LNG
– although the position of the government on the planned EastMed pipeline,
which is expected to transport gas through Cyprus and Greece, is still cautious.
After his visit to Israel in June 2022, Prime Minister Mario Draghi confirmed the
government’s intention to cooperate with countries in the region to diversify away
from Russian gas, but did not mention the EastMed project.
9
The Italian strategy to end gas dependence on Russia started to unfold in April 2022
with one of its most important deals. Prime Minister Draghi and Algeria’s President
Abdelmadjid Tebboune signed a memorandum of understanding to strengthen
energy cooperation; this was followed by several agreements between energy
companies Eni and Sonatrach. These deals will increase gas exports to Italy and
foresee an accelerated development of gas fields in Algeria, leading to an additional
3 bcm in the short term and another 6 bcm by 2023, split between LNG and gas.
The Italy–Algeria intergovernmental summit in July scaled up plans, announcing
an additional 4 bcm to be supplied in 2022 and reiterated commitments to develop
clean energy.
10
These agreements make Algeria the main Italian gas supplier, with
approximately 30 bcm per year.
11
In April 2022, Eni also signed an agreement with Egypt to increase gas production
and exports through LNG, which will reach 3 bcm by 2022.
12
As stated by Minister
https://finanza.lastampa.it/News/2022/06/21/gas-mite-non-necessario-livello-di-allerta-via-ad-
acquisti-carbone/MTc5XzIwMjItMDYtMjFfVExC.
8
Italian Senate, “Informativa del Ministro della transizione ecologica…”, cit., p. 12; Italian Parliament-
COPASIR, Relazione sulle conseguenze del conflitto tra Russia e Ucraina…, cit., p. 13.
9
Vanessa Ricciardi, “Draghi in Israele non si sbilancia sul gasdotto EastMed mentre Eni punta sul
Gnl”, in Domani, 14 June 2022, https://www.editorialedomani.it/politica/mondo/draghi-israele-
gasdotto-eastmed-eni-gnl-k09k3h65.
10
Carlo Marroni, “Gas, Draghi: ‘Algeria diventato il nostro primo fornitore’”, in Il Sole 24 Ore, 18
July 2022, https://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/gas-draghi-algeria-diventato-nostro-primo-fornitore-
AEL40EnB.
11
Ibid.
12
Eni, Eni and EGAS Agree to Increase Egypt’s Gas Production and Supply, 13 April 2022, https://
www.eni.com/en-IT/media/press-release/2022/04/eni-and-egas-agree-increase-egypt-s-gas-
production-and-supply.html.
剩余21页未读,继续阅读
资源评论
如此醉123
- 粉丝: 231
- 资源: 9万+
上传资源 快速赚钱
- 我的内容管理 展开
- 我的资源 快来上传第一个资源
- 我的收益 登录查看自己的收益
- 我的积分 登录查看自己的积分
- 我的C币 登录后查看C币余额
- 我的收藏
- 我的下载
- 下载帮助
安全验证
文档复制为VIP权益,开通VIP直接复制
信息提交成功