没有合适的资源?快使用搜索试试~ 我知道了~
巴克莱-美股-商业与专业服务业-12月份不出意料地指数(MSCI)下降-17-49页.pdf
需积分: 0 0 下载量 124 浏览量
2023-07-26
11:48:42
上传
评论
收藏 886KB PDF 举报
温馨提示
试读
49页
巴克莱-美股-商业与专业服务业-12月份不出意料地指数(MSCI)下降-17-49页.pdf
资源推荐
资源详情
资源评论
Equity Research
7 January 2019
CORE
Barclays Capital Inc. and/or one of its affiliates does and seeks to do business with
companies covered in its research reports. As a result, investors should be aware that the
firm may have a conflict of interest that could affect the objectivity of this report. Investors
should consider this report as only a single factor in making their investment decision.
PLEASE SEE ANALYST CERTIFICATION(S) AND IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES BEGINNING ON PAGE 40.
For Your ‘Information Services’
Unsurprisingly weak Dec. for Ratings
(MCO/SPGI) & Index (MSCI); lower #s
Credit Issuance (MCO/SPGI): In the midst of a volatile equity market correction,
December issuance was unsurprisingly down sharply (-57% y/y; already a
seasonally quiet month), bringing 4Q to down 30%+… All asset classes were down
y/y (same as November); and notably there was no U.S./European HY corporate
issuance. Note that January is typically a relatively slow month for issuance, and likely
even moreso this year if markets remain choppy. …and as we mark-to-market, we
lower our 4Q Ratings growth estimates to (14)-(15)% vs. prior (9)-(11)%; and for
conservatism’s sake also tweak 2019 to +2% (from +3%). The resulting changes put
us below 2018 guidance for MCO ($7.38 vs. $7.50-7.65 guide) and SPGI ($8.45 vs.
$8.50-8.60 guide); and we now model in +HSD EPS growth for both in 2019. In this
backdrop, we think SPGI is better positioned given a) greater diversification (50% of
AOI tied to Ratings vs. MCO at 75%+); b) more self-help productivity initiatives; and
c) balance sheet flexibility with ~$2B of cash and leverage already at its 1.75x target.
Index & ETF AUMs (MSCI/SPGI): Clearly the pieces tied to AUM fees (40% of MSCI
Index; 60%+ for SPGI) face market depreciation pressure (e.g. SPX -14%; ACWI ex-
U.S. -12% in 4Q); but both co’s have offsets. Notably, flows into ETFs remained
positive during the pullback; e.g. MSCI ETF AUM was -6% from 12/31/17 to 12/31/18
vs. ACWI ex U.S. down -16%. For SPGI, in the near-term there should be a benefit from
higher derivative trading volumes (20% of mix) given higher market volatility. MSCI,
meanwhile, still has 60% of Index that is Subscription-oriented and growing 10%+.
U.S. Financial Services Hiring (FDS/TRI/SPGI): Trends remain positive... December
hiring was up +2.9% y/y (14th straight month of 2%+ growth); with buy-side (+3.3% in
Nov) and sell-side (+2.8%) both positively contributing. …and while pressures remain,
we maintain EW ratings on FDS and TRI. FDS’s in-line F1Q19 (earnings 12/17) led to
stock weakness during the broader equity sell-off, but we still think it screens as
relatively defensive with a stable growth algorithm (+MSD organic; +100bps of margin
expansion; +LDD EPS growth). For TRI, we think recent relative outperformance fairly
accounts for momentum at “new TRI”; optionality from the Refinitiv stub; and scarcity
value for Canadian investors.
Mortgage Originations (EFX/TRU/FICO): MBA is forecasting 10%+ $-volume
declines in 4Q, bringing 2018 to -7% (+4% purchase; -27% refi). Initial 2019
forecast is for -1% volumes (+4% purchase; -17% refi). By comparison, ELLI at our
TMT conference said its forecast for the mortgage market is to be down 5-6% in 2019
(in unit terms). Remember that EFX is the credit bureau with outsized mortgage
exposure (~20%), while EXPN/TRU/FICO all have <10% mortgage revenues. Non-
mortgage credit trends remain healthy – +8% in Oct., including revolving +11%.
INDUSTRY UPDATE
U.S. Business & Professional Services
NEUTRAL
Unchanged
For a full list of our ratings, price target and
earnings changes in this report, please see
table on page 2.
U.S. Business & Professional Services
Manav Patnaik
+1 212 526 2983
manav.patnaik@barclays.com
BCI, US
Gregory Bardi, CFA
+ 1 212 526 7188
gregory.bardi@barclays.com
BCI, US
Ryan Leonard
+1 212 526 2135
ryan.leonard@barclays.com
BCI, US
Barclays | For Your 'Information Services'
7 January 2019 2
Summary of our Ratings, Price Targets and Earnings Changes in this Report (all changes are shown in bold)
Company
Rating
Price
Price Target
EPS FY1 (E)
EPS FY2 (E)
Old
New
04-Jan-19
Old
New
%Chg
Old
New
%Chg
Old
New
%Chg
U.S. Business & Professional Services
Neu
Neu
Moody's Corp. (MCO)
OW
OW
143.28
175.00
165.00
-6
7.45
7.38
-1
8.13
7.90
-3
MSCI Inc. (MSCI)
OW
OW
146.60
175.00
165.00
-6
5.15
5.18
1
5.86
5.82
-1
S&P Global Inc. (SPGI)
OW
OW
172.26
220.00
205.00
-7
8.50
8.45
-1
9.26
9.20
-1
Source: Barclays Research. Share prices and target prices are shown in the primary listing currency and EPS estimates are shown in the reporting currency.
FY1(E): Current fiscal year estimates by Barclays Research. FY2(E): Next fiscal year estimates by Barclays Research.
Stock Rating: OW: Overweight; EW: Equal Weight; UW: Underweight; RS: Rating Suspended
Industry View: Pos: Positive; Neu: Neutral; Neg: Negative
Valuation Methodology and Risks
U.S. Business & Professional Services
Moody's Corp. (MCO)
Valuation Methodology: Our PT of $165 uses a SOTP-based blended multiple of 18.8x our FY20 cash EPS estimate of $8.79.
Risks which May Impede the Achievement of the Barclays Research Valuation and Price Target: With rates rising and corporate tax reform
potentially lowering the relative attractiveness of debt financing, MCO is facing a potentially noisy period for credit issuance. While the DOJ
settlement removes MCO's biggest legal overhang, legal and regulatory overhangs remain. Furthermore, issuance lumpiness could cause
negative earnings revisions. While unlikely today, an alternative to ratings could meaningfully pressure the shares as well.
MSCI Inc. (MSCI)
Valuation Methodology: Our PT of $165 is based on ~24.6x our FY20 EPS estimate of $6.70.
Risks which May Impede the Achievement of the Barclays Research Valuation and Price Target: a) Fee pressure for ETF providers and active
managers impacting index growth; b) a tough backdrop and cost pressures for investment firms weighing on Analytics growth; c) key client risk
– with BlackRock accounting for 10% of revenues (and 17% of Index); and d) weak global equity markets weighing on MSCI's ETF AUM.
S&P Global Inc. (SPGI)
Valuation Methodology: Our PT of $205 uses a SOTP-based blended multiple of 20.2x our FY20 cash EPS estimate of $10.15.
Risks which May Impede the Achievement of the Barclays Research Valuation and Price Target: Risks are mainly macro related - issuance
trends for Ratings; growth in ETF AUM for Indices; energy prices and health of market for Platts; and market data demand for Market
Intelligence.
Source: Barclays Research.
Barclays | For Your 'Information Services'
7 January 2019 3
CONTENTS
Our ‘FYI’ monthly focuses on our financial info services companies and includes updates on:
1) credit issuance trends and forecasts (re: MCO/SPGI); 2) financial services hiring (re: FDS,
TRI, SPGI’s Market Intelligence); and 3) other relevant data points.
MCO, SPGI, MSCI - MODEL AND PT UPDATES ......................................... 4
Tweaking #s lower for macro pressures (issuance for CRA’s; equity weakness for Index)... ... 4
...and taking down PTs to account for broad market de-rating. ....................................................... 4
CREDIT ISSUANCE TRACKER & COMMENTARY ....................................... 5
December issuance (-57% y/y; -32% 4Q; -14% in 2018): A Quiet Place ...................................... 5
U.S. IG Corps (-71% Dec; -32% 4Q): Slowest month in recent memory........................................ 6
U.S. HY Corps (-100% Dec; -73% 4Q): Zero, zilch, zip ........................................................................ 7
U.S. CLOs (-44% Dec; -22% 4Q): Light end to the year, but record 2018 ..................................... 8
U.S. CMBS (-44% Dec; -35% 4Q): Ended the year very quietly ......................................................... 9
U.S. ABS (-20% Dec; -16% 4Q): A bright spot in 2018 (+6% y/y) ................................................ 10
U.S. Munis (-66% Dec; -41% 4Q): Against record Dec’17 comp .................................................. 11
Euro IG corps (-42% Dec; -17% 4Q): A typically quiet December ................................................ 12
European HY (-100% Dec; -73% 4Q) – Nada, nothing .................................................................... 13
U.S. Historical Issuance .............................................................................................................................. 14
International Historical Issuance ............................................................................................................. 15
BARCLAYS/S&P FORECASTING ~FLAT ISSUANCE GROWTH IN 201916
2019 outlook is calling for ~flat issuance growth ................................................................................ 16
More on our constructive long-term view of issuance ..................................................................... 18
WHY WE THINK MSCI/INDEX REMAINS WELL POSITIONED .............. 21
ABF (20-25% of mix) – active-to-passive trends in its favor .......................................................... 21
Index Subscription (~35% of mix) – remarkably consistent performance.................................. 23
FIN. INFO – HEALTHY DEMAND, BUT 2019 COULD GET TOUGHER . 25
Securities industry (buy + sell side) above pre-crisis levels ............................................................. 25
Buy-side – Relatively healthy trends, but tough market backdrop now ...................................... 25
Sell-side – Healthiest y/y hiring growth since Financial Crisis ........................................................ 26
How resilient have our market data names been? ............................................................................. 27
December employment (+312k; 3.9%): What’s not to like? ............................................................ 29
OTHER MACRO-DATA TRACKER ............................................................... 30
MBA Originations (Re: CBs): Starting the year expecting -1% $-volumes in 2019 .................. 31
C&I Loans (re: DNB): Growth starting to reaccelerate, led by small bank lending .................... 32
Consumer Credit (Re: EFX, TRU, FICO): Strong growth in Oct (+7.7%), including revolving
(+10.7%) ........................................................................................................................................................ 33
Small Biz Optimism (Re: DNB, EFX, EXPN): Weakens in Nov, still high historically ................... 34
CALENDAR OF EVENTS ................................................................................. 39
Barclays | For Your 'Information Services'
7 January 2019 4
MCO, SPGI, MSCI - MODEL AND PT UPDATES
Tweaking #s lower for macro pressures (issuance for CRA’s;
equity weakness for Index)...
Taking down 4Q Ratings growth estimates to (14)-(15)% from prior (9)-(11)%... as
market volatility in December meant 4Q ended even worse than expected. The resulting
impact lowers our EPS, and we are currently below 2018 guidance for both MCO ($7.38
vs. $7.50-7.65 guide and Street $7.50) and SPGI ($8.45 vs. $8.50-8.60 guide and Street
$8.50).
...and for conservatism’s sake, we also tweak down 2019 Ratings growth estimate
from +3% to +2%. Our new FY19 EPS estimate for MCO is $7.90 or ~8% y/y growth (vs.
prior $8.13 and Street at $8.07); and for SPGI our FY19 EPS estimate is $9.20 or ~8%
growth (vs. prior $9.26 and Street $9.29).
Lower Index assumptions (re: MSCI, SPGI) for weaker equity prices on AUM-based
revenues. Impressively though, MSCI ETF AUM was only down ~6% from Dec’17 to
Dec’18 despite the MSCI ACWI ex U.S. being down ~16% (implying steady inflows).
Note: We also updated our SPGI Indices revenues for the pullback, but note that volatility
should benefit its transaction-related fees (~25% of mix; and we assume +55% growth
in 4Q).
...and taking down PTs to account for broad market de-
rating.
Despite the macro headwinds, we continue to believe that MCO, SPGI, and MSCI should
trade at healthy premiums to the market (on updated/lowered #s), given their respective
“benchmark” statuses, high operating leverage, and strong FCF conversion (which supports
attractive capital return. Updated price targets below:
SPGI PT to $205 (prior $220), or ~20x our FY20 cash EPS estimate of $10.15. Prior PT
of $220 was based on 21.6x prior FY20 EPS estimate of $10.20.
MCO PT to $165 (prior $175), or ~19x our FY20 cash EPS estimate of $8.79. Prior PT
of $175 was based on 19.3x our prior FY20 cash EPS estimate of $9.05.
MSCI PT to $165 (prior $175), or ~24.6x our FY20 EPS estimate of $6.70. Prior PT of
$175 was based on 26x our FY20 EPS estimate of $6.77.
Barclays | For Your 'Information Services'
7 January 2019 5
CREDIT ISSUANCE TRACKER & COMMENTARY
December issuance (-57% y/y; -32% 4Q; -14% in 2018): A Quiet Place
FIGURE 1
2018 Issuance vs. 2017 (in millions)
Source: Barclays Equity Research and Credit Research, S&P, Moody’s
2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018* y/y 2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018* y/y 2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018* y/y 2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018* y/y 2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018*
y/y
Jan $107 $155 $219 42% $156 -29% Jan $19 $6 $19 217% $24 28% Jan $6 $3 $2 -40% $5 167% Jan $7 $33 $96 191% $48 -50% Jan $5 $1 $2 150% $7 250%
Feb $117 $113 $92 -19% $109 19% Feb $31 $8 $19 150% $12 -35% Feb $12 $5 $4 -21% $5 24% Feb $20 $18 $43 139% $51 19% Feb $8 $2 $9 309% $16 78%
Mar $157 $135 $145 7% $122 -16% Mar $37 $18 $43 134% $27 -38% Mar $11 $8 $9 5% $9 8% Mar $21 $25 $71 184% $59 -17% Mar $16 $4 $9 120% $11 22%
1st Qtr. $381 $403 $456
13%
$387 -15% 1st Qtr. $87 $32 $80
153%
$63 -22% 1st Qtr. $29 $16 $15
-12%
$19 32% 1st Qtr. $48 $76 $210
176%
$158 -25% 1st Qtr. $29 $7 $20
182%
$34 70%
Apr $122 $122 $101 -17% $138 37% Apr $34 $31 $16 -48% $17 7% Apr $9 $3 $4 27% $4 5% Apr $32 $20 $61 207% $59 -3% Apr $12 $6 $10 67% $11 10%
May $155 $190 $163 -14% $91 -44% May $34 $28 $26 -7% $14 -46% May $8 $6 $9 42% $6 -29% May $66 $32 $49 55% $73 49% May $6 $5 $10 96% $12 22%
Jun $101 $87 $84 -3% $106 27% Jun $21 $22 $20 -12% $15 -24% Jun $10 $2 $11 547% $12 9% Jun $48 $69 $55 -20% $63 15% Jun $13 $8 $15 97% $13 -13%
2nd Qtr. $378 $399 $348
-13%
$336 -3% 2nd Qtr. $89 $82 $62
-24%
$47 -25% 2nd Qtr. $27 $11 $23
118%
$22 -6% 2nd Qtr. $147 $120 $165
37%
$195 18% 2nd Qtr. $31 $19 $35
87%
$36 3%
Jul $146 $118 $119 0% $63 -47% Jul $12 $13 $11 -17% $7 -32% Jul $8 $6 $7 17% $8 14% Jul $26 $21 $45 114% $40 -11% Jul $7 $6 $9 55% $10 11%
Aug $52 $118 $103 -13% $71 -31% Aug $10 $17 $18 6% $17 -6% Aug $7 $5 $11 120% $5 -55% Aug $15 $47 $35 -26% $15 -57% Aug $6 $6 $12 107% $14 17%
Sep $109 $156 $146 -7% $139 -5% Sep $19 $25 $37 47% $36 -2% Sep $8 $9 $9 0% $4 -56% Sep $11 $55 $22 -60% $42 91% Sep $6 $8 $10 22% $8 -20%
3rd Qtr. $307 $393 $367
-6%
$273 -26% 3rd Qtr. $41 $55 $66
19%
$61 -8% 3rd Qtr. $23 $20 $27
35%
$17 -37% 3rd Qtr. $52 $123 $102
-17%
$97 -5% 3rd Qtr. $19 $20 $31
57%
$32 3%
Oct $113 $131 $138 6% $102 -26% Oct $9 $13 $23 72% $12 -47% Oct $9 $8 $10 25% $8 -25% Oct $18 $75 $42 -44% $55 31% Oct $7 $8 $12 43% $9 -25%
Nov $97 $73 $117 61% $88 -25% Nov $23 $15 $26 73% $6 -77% Nov $8 $12 $10 -19% $6 -37% Nov $21 $43 $51 17% $25 -51% Nov $4 $9 $13 45% $12 -4%
Dec $56 $39 $42 8% $12 -71% Dec $3 $19 $18 -5% $0 -100% Dec $5 $9 $9 5% $5 -44% Dec $9 $66 $35 -47% $30 -14% Dec $8 $10 $9 -5% $5 -44%
4th Qtr. $266 $242 $298
23%
$202 -32% 4th Qtr. $35 $47 $67
42%
$18 -73% 4th Qtr. $22 $29 $29
0%
$19 -35% 4th Qtr. $48 $184 $128
-31%
$110 -14% 4th Qtr. $19 $27 $34
26%
$26 -22%
Full Year $1,332 $1,436 $1,469
2%
$1,198 -18% Full Year $252 $216 $276
28%
$189 -32% Full Year $101 $76 $94
23%
$77 -18% Full Year $295 $504 $605
20%
$560 -7% Full Year $98 $72 $119
66%
$128 7%
2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018* y/y 2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018* y/y 2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018* y/y 2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018* y/y 2015 2016 2017
y/y
2018*
y/y
Jan $21 $11 $18 64% $27 47% Jan $29 $26 $36 40% $22 -40% Jan € 70 € 35 € 62 79% € 52 -16% Jan € 13 € 1 € 6 567% € 6 5% Jan £2 £2 £5 172% £5 8%
Feb $21 $19 $20 7% $24 20% Feb $33 $32 $23 -26% $18 -24% Feb € 57 € 51 € 45 -13% € 37 -18% Feb € 11 € 2 € 8 233% € 3 -59% Feb £4 £2 £5 194% £4 -21%
Mar $20 $13 $27 106% $34 26% Mar $46 $43 $33 -23% $26 -20% Mar € 67 € 81 € 67 -17% € 67 0% Mar € 14 € 11 € 12 9% € 9 -29% Mar £3 £2 £5 141% £4 -19%
1st Qtr. $62 $43 $65
52%
$85 30% 1st Qtr. $108 $100 $92
-8%
$66 -29% 1st Qtr. € 195 € 167 € 174
4%
€ 156 -10% 1st Qtr. € 38 € 14 € 26
81%
€ 18 -30% 1st Qtr. £6 £6 £15
166%
£13 -11%
Apr $20 $14 $24 66% $22 -8% Apr $41 $35 $31 -14% $32 3% Apr € 42 € 66 € 24 -63% € 42 73% Apr € 14 € 16 € 7 -55% € 9 23% Apr £3 £2 £5 124% £4 -13%
May $24 $25 $26 2% $33 25% May $37 $42 $39 -9% $35 -9% May € 49 € 73 € 70 -4% € 44 -37% May € 4 € 8 € 3 -68% € 4 56% May £4 £2 £6 256% £3 -56%
Jun $15 $16 $22 34% $30 40% Jun $40 $48 $40 -18% $33 -16% Jun € 26 € 25 € 54 116% € 35 -34% Jun € 6 € 5 € 9 72% € 6 -37% Jun £3 £1 £5 500% £5 2%
2nd Qtr. $59 $56 $72
28%
$85 18% 2nd Qtr. $118 $126 $109
-14%
$100 -8% 2nd Qtr. € 117 € 164 € 148
-9%
€ 122 -18% 2nd Qtr. € 23 € 29 € 19
-34%
€ 18 -2% 2nd Qtr. £7 £5 £15
238%
£12 -24%
Jul $17 $23 $17 -26% $23 35% Jul $35 $29 $25 -14% $27 8% Jul € 24 € 29 € 23 -22% € 35 53% Jul € 9 € 3 € 7 115% € 4 -41% Jul £2 £2 £8 230% £5 -38%
Aug $14 $13 $25 92% $17 -32% Aug $32 $47 $37 -20% $34 -9% Aug € 13 € 20 € 22 9% € 37 70% Aug € 1 € 2 € 0 -100% € 1 na Aug £2 £9 £2 -76% £2 0%
Sep $12 $21 $17 -19% $15 -12% Sep $24 $40 $29 -26% $25 -14% Sep € 55 € 48 € 52 8% € 59 15% Sep € 2 € 12 € 11 -11% € 8 -25% Sep £1 £8 £7 -17% £8 22%
3rd Qtr. $43 $57 $59
3%
$55 -7% 3rd Qtr. $92 $115 $92
-21%
$86 -6% 3rd Qtr. € 92 € 97 € 96
-1%
€ 131 36% 3rd Qtr. € 12 € 18 € 18
1%
€ 13 -28% 3rd Qtr. £5 £19 £17
-14%
£15 -8%
Oct $23 $28 $35 25% $37 4% Oct $35 $54 $39 -27% $37 -6% Oct € 32 € 48 € 29 -39% € 24 -20% Oct € 3 € 5 € 13 191% € 3 -78% Oct £3 £2 £6 275% £3 -55%
Nov $11 $14 $27 93% $16 -41% Nov $25 $32 $44 37% $28 -36% Nov € 48 € 41 € 55 35% € 49 -11% Nov € 3 € 3 € 7 100% € 4 -41% Nov £3 £3 £6 148% £3 -60%
Dec $3 $8 $10 23% $8 -20% Dec $25 $19 $64 230% $22 -66% Dec € 12 € 9 € 10 10% € 6 -42% Dec € 4 € 1 € 6 544% € 0 -100% Dec £2 £2 £1 -53% £0 -63%
4th Qtr. $38 $50 $72
44%
$61 -16% 4th Qtr. $85 $105 $147
40%
$87 -41% 4th Qtr. € 92 € 98 € 95
-4%
€ 79 -17% 4th Qtr. € 11 € 9 € 26
192%
€ 7 -73% 4th Qtr. £8 £6 £13
124%
£6 -58%
Full Year $202 $206 $268
30%
$285 6% Full Year $403 $446 $439
-2%
$338 -23% Full Year € 496 € 526 € 513
-2%
€ 487 -5% Full Year € 85 € 70 € 89
27%
€ 57 -36% Full Year £32 £35 £60
69%
£46 -24%
U.S. Non-Mortgage ABS
U.S. Municipal
Euro Investment Grade
U.S. Investment Grade
U.S. High Yield
U.S. Non-Agency CMBS
U.S. Leveraged Loans
U.S. CLOs
GBP Investment Grade
Pan-European High Yield
剩余48页未读,继续阅读
资源评论
2201_75761617
- 粉丝: 21
- 资源: 7339
上传资源 快速赚钱
- 我的内容管理 展开
- 我的资源 快来上传第一个资源
- 我的收益 登录查看自己的收益
- 我的积分 登录查看自己的积分
- 我的C币 登录后查看C币余额
- 我的收藏
- 我的下载
- 下载帮助
安全验证
文档复制为VIP权益,开通VIP直接复制
信息提交成功