1646 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INSTRUMENTATION AND MEASUREMENT, VOL. 54, NO. 4, AUGUST 2005
Modeling of Switched-Capacitor Delta–Sigma
Modulators in SIMULINK
Hashem Zare-Hoseini, Izzet Kale, and Omid Shoaei, Member, IEEE
Abstract—Precise behavioral modeling of switched-capacitor
16
modulators is presented. Considering noise (switches’ and
op-amps’ thermal noise), clock jitter, nonidealities of integrators
and op-amps including finite dc-gain (DCG) and unity gain band-
width, slew-limiting, DCG nonlinearities and the input parasitic
capacitance, quantizer hysteresis, switches’ clock-feedthrough,
and charge injection, exhaustive behavioral simulations that are
close models of the transistor-level ones can be performed. The
DCG nonlinearity of the integrators, which is not considered in
many
16
modulators’ modeling attempts, is analyzed, estimated,
and modeled. It is shown that neglecting this parameter would
lead to a significant underestimation of the modulators’ behavior
and increase the noise floor as well as the harmonic distortion
at the output of the modulator. Evaluation and validation of the
models were done via behavioral and transistor-level simulations
for a second-order modulator using SIMULINK and HSPICE
with a generic 0.35-
m CMOS technology. The effects of the
nonidealities and nonlinearities are clearly seen when compared
to the ideal modulator in the behavioral and actual modulator in
the circuit-level environment.
Index Terms—Charge injection, clock feedthrough, correlated
double sampling, delta–sigma modulators, hysteresis, nonideality,
nonlinearity, SIMULINK, switched capacitor.
I. INTRODUCTION
A
MONG the oversampling converters, ones have
achieved the most attraction recently in high-resolution
applications due to their noise shaping behavior that leads
them to inherent superior linearity, simple realization, and low
sensitivity to circuit imperfections [1]. Such converters reduce
the need for complex analog circuit implementation and, due to
their oversampling nature, act as the most suitable architectures
for accurate low to moderately high frequency applications.
modulators can be realized in either the continuous-time
(CT) or switched-capacitor (SC) approach. While CT modula-
tors have the advantages of lower power consumption, higher
speed, and intrinsic anti-aliasing filtering, they suffer from the
difficulty of designing, sensitivity to clock jitter, and also excess
loop delay [2]. As far as the implementation technique is con-
cerned, SC modulators are preferred to CT modulators because
they can be more efficiently realized in standard CMOS tech-
nology [1], [3]. Moreover, they provide a highly controllable
Manuscript received June 15, 2004; revised April 15, 2005.
H. Zare-Hoseini and I. Kale are with the Applied DSP and VLSI Research
Group, Department of Electronic Systems, University of Westminster, London,
W1W 6UW, U.K. (e-mail: h.zhoseini@wmin.ac.uk)
O. Shoaei is with the IC Design Laboratory, Electrical and Computer Engi-
neering Department, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TIM.2005.851085
design as well as being more robust to clock jitter and feed-
back delay problems. In this paper, the SC
modulators are
considered.
Although
modulators have relatively straightforward
realizations, the appropriate architecture selection, including
single loop or MASH, loop filter type, order and coefficients,
and the number of bits of the quantizer, would be a difficult
task. Also, the requirements of the building blocks such as
integrators’ bandwidth, dc-gain (DCG), slew rate and output
swings, the quantizer threshold, the digital-to-analog con-
verter (DAC), the switches, and the clock and power supply
accuracy cannot be easily estimated. Several techniques have
been used for time-domain analysis of these modulators listed
and discussed briefly in [3], such as SPICE, SWITCAP, and
table-lookup models. For instance, the SPICE simulations are
precise, but they take extremely long times especially for very
high-resolution narrow-band modulators because of both long
period cycles and the high accuracy needed. Hence, choosing
the optimized architecture and estimating the requirements of
building blocks is a very time-consuming procedure in tran-
sistor-level design and simulation (SPICE). There is a need for
a time-efficient and accurate simulation environment. To this
effect, the user friendly, versatile SIMULINK tool was chosen
to develop detailed models of the modulators’ building blocks.
The popular SIMULINK simulator proved to be an excellent
time-efficient candidate for this initial task.
In this paper, detailed analytical models of the basic building
blocks (integrators and op-amps) and also the nonidealities of
a typical modulator are presented, followed by SIMULINK
models of them. Most previous
modulator models have
not considered the effect of DCG nonlinearity in integrators,
leading to a significant underestimation of the modulators’ be-
havior and harmonic distortion. In this paper, this is analyzed,
estimated, and modeled in SIMULINK, as well as other blocks
of a typical
modulator. Moreover, several behavioral and
transistor-level simulations were performed in SIMULINK
and HSPICE using a generic 0.35-
m CMOS technology to
validate the analyses and models. Since in the first stage of very
high-resolution modulators correlated-double-sampled (CDS)
integrators are routinely used to attenuate the effect of offset
and flicker noise, for comparison purposes, both typical and
CDS integrators are discussed in this paper.
In Section II, the integrator characteristics such as finite
DCG, nonlinear DCG, and settling behavior are presented.
Section III presents noise contributors such as sampling and
op-amp thermal noise. Switch nonidealities are considered next
following with a discussion about clock jitter. In Section VI, a
brief review of quantizer nonidealities are discussed. Then the
0018-9456/$20.00 © 2005 IEEE
Authorized licensed use limited to: Harbin Institute of Technology. Downloaded on June 28,2010 at 08:50:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.