**Attention Spoilers**<br /><br />First of all, let me say that Rob Roy is one of the best films of the 90's. It was an amazing achievement for all those involved, especially the acting of Liam Neeson, Jessica Lange, John Hurt, Brian Cox, and Tim Roth. Michael Canton Jones painted a wonderful portrait of the honor and dishonor that men can represent in themselves. But alas...<br /><br />it constantly, and unfairly gets compared to "Braveheart". These are two entirely different films, probably only similar in the fact that they are both about Scots in historical Scotland. Yet, this comparison frequently bothers me because it seems to be almost assumed that "Braveheart" is a better film than "Rob Roy". I like "Braveheart" a lot, but the idea of comparing it to "Rob Roy" is a little insulting to me. To put quite simply, I love "Braveheart", but it is a pale shadow to how much I love "Rob Roy". Here are my particular reasons...<br /><br />-"Rob Roy" is about real people.<br /><br />Let's face it, the William Wallace in "Braveheart" is not a real person. He's a legend, a martyr, a larger than life figurehead. Because of this depiction, he is also a perfect person, never doing wrong, and basically showing his Scot countrymen to the promised land. When he finally does fail, it is not to his fault. Like Jesus, he is betrayed by the very people he trusted most. He even goes through the worst kind of torture because he wants freedom so much.<br /><br />The depiction of Wallace is very well done and effective. But it really doesn't inspire or intrigue me. I find human ambiguity far more facinating than human perfection. That is why "The Last Temptation of Christ" is a better film than "King of Kings", and that is also one of the reasons why I think "Rob Roy" is better than "Braveheart". Rob Roy may be heroic and brave, but he is far from perfect. He makes several mistakes that affected the lives of many of his loved ones. Now sure, not bearing false claim against the Duke of Argyll was an act of nobility and courage, but it was also an act of egoism and self centeredness. Let us not forget that the kinfolk that he had claimed to protect were driven homeless by the end of the film because of this act. But Rob did the best he could, and that was all you could ask of him.<br /><br />Rob's Wife Mary, is also a normal, ambigious person. Let us start though, with how she looks in this film. Sure, she's beautiful, but she doesn't wear makeup and she basically allows her natural beauty to show. Compare this with the two loves (or one, depending on your point of view) of William Wallace in "Braveheart". Now these two ladies are hot, but hardly indicitive of how women looked at the time (especially the lay persons). Maybe not a fair comparison, but just another example of how Rob Roy's attempts for accuracy are far more effective.<br /><br />Throughout "Rob Roy", Mary has to live with her vicious rape by the dastardly carrion, Cunningham. She feels compelled to tell Rob of her struggle, but doesn't because she knows that Rob must seek revenge for her rape. Such revenge would surely mean the death of Rob, and Mary is not prepared for such a sacrifice.<br /><br />The villains in "Rob Roy" are equally as compelling. Although the enemies in "Braveheart" are well written, they are hardly original. Robert the Bruce, a man both brave and cowardly, is plagued by moral decisions that are all to familar in the fictional realm. Should he take his claim as the king of Scotland, or should he betray Wallace in order to ensure the safety of his family name? Bruce is the most ambigious character in "Braveheart", but from Brutus in "Julius Ceasar" to Fredo in "The Godfather Part II", these types of characters are hardly original. Longshanks, although a compelling villain in his own right, is very one dimensional. He is the epidemy of evil, and his tyrant ways stand in direct contrast to Wallace's heroism.<br /><br />"Rob Roy" has three villains that are wonderful in their chicanery. First of all, let's start with Marquis of Montrose. He is a man who is so obsessed with his self image, that he's willing to let an innocent man suffer because of it. "See to it that I am not mocked" are his favorite words to his "factor". He is a man obsessed with power, upset that a man of great noble bearing as the Duke of Argyll can be considered of greater providency then him. He is shamefully self obsessed and insecure. He is an evil aristocrat, but in ways that make him unique.<br /><br />Cunningham and Callarn are the conspirators in "Rob Roy", and are also Roy's direct assailants. Callarn is so cunning in his cowardace that he is almost comical. He will do anything to maintain the good will of the Marquis, which includes backstabbing and trickery. Cunningham is a compelling character in that he seems to have been raised to do whatever he can to obtain status and the affection of the Marquis. He needs a father, little does he know that the Marquis is his real father. Therefore, when the opportunity to obtain wealth comes from Callarn, he grabs it without even questioning it. He is very much like the evil of modern man, so self centered and vain that he cares not about the consequences of his actions on others.<br /><br />Many have criticized Tim Roth's performance in this film as overacting. Hogwash I say. It is clear that Cunningham is not simply evil but also psychopath throughout the film. In a world where a man and his stepson can go around shooting random people for amusement, is Cunningham too much of an unbelievable character? We live in a society where people seem to have decreased the value of human life. "Rob Roy" simply teaches us that only the circumstances of this decreased value has changed. It is a problem throughout human history that the vanity of the human heart will not allow for the capacity for compassion. Rob Roy and Mary give us hope that goodness will prevail, but snakes will always exist in our world.<br /><br />Another character that I find fascinating is the Duke of Argyll. He is a true nobleman, and his values of honesty and courtesy are in direct contrast to the Marquis. He appreciates the bravery of Rob Roy and Mary, and has a direct vexation for the Marquis and his factor. He gives the world hope for the people of power. Hopefully, people like the Marquis are an exception and not the rule.<br /><br />- The final duel in "Rob Roy" is more exciting then 10 of the battle scenes in "Braveheart".<br /><br />One thing I get tired of is people telling me that "Braveheart" is a better film because of the battle scenes. First of all, battle scenes are hardly original. From "Spartacus" to "Gladiator", Hollywood has had a long tradition of historical European battle scenes. "Braveheart" has some of the best battle scenes ever put on film, but they suffer from one important problem. These battle scenes have no context except for the fight for freedom.<br /><br />Now, don't get me wrong, duels are hardly original either. In fact, there are probably 10 times as many films with duels as there are with battle scenes. But the context of the duel between Cunningham and Rob Roy is a beauty to behold. It is one of the greatest scenes in film history. Let me explain why...<br /><br />First of all, the fighting style and the bearing of the two characters in this duel describe the characters perfectly. Cunningham is effette and dangerous, Rob Roy is strong and courageous. Cunningham uses a fencing sword while Rob uses a broadsword. Cunningham fights with quick tricky movements, while Roy's fighting style is more obvious.<br /><br />The whole film, from the deliberately slow first half to the exciting second half, is leading up to this moment. It is powerful stuff, and it is clear that Rob must exterminate this menacing evil that has plagued his whole world. When Rob finally gets the upper hand (literally and figuratively,) it is one of the greatest moments in film history. Rob wins because he
没有合适的资源?快使用搜索试试~ 我知道了~
温馨提示
本资源是基于LSTM分类的电影评论情感分析Python源码及项目说明,包含IMDB情感分析数据集和预训练的词典向量模型。通过使用长短期记忆网络(LSTM),该项目能够有效捕捉电影评论中的长期依赖关系,从而准确判断评论的情感倾向。IMDB数据集广泛用于文本分类任务,包含了50,000条带有情感标签的评论。预训练的词典向量模型则提高了分析的准确性和效率。该资源适合计算机科学、数据科学及相关专业的学习者,旨在帮助用户掌握深度学习在自然语言处理中的应用,特别是情感分析技术。
资源推荐
资源详情
资源评论
收起资源包目录
基于LSTM分类的电影评论情感分析python源码+项目说明(IMDB情感分析数据集+训练好的词典向量模型).zip (2000个子文件)
README.md 170B
4383_9.txt 10KB
7778_10.txt 7KB
1321_10.txt 6KB
11030_8.txt 6KB
8222_9.txt 6KB
10318_7.txt 6KB
3543_10.txt 6KB
8860_8.txt 6KB
2544_8.txt 6KB
10751_10.txt 6KB
5584_8.txt 6KB
9089_9.txt 5KB
6657_9.txt 5KB
1582_8.txt 5KB
1475_8.txt 5KB
11386_8.txt 5KB
2362_9.txt 5KB
5470_10.txt 5KB
11953_8.txt 5KB
3821_9.txt 5KB
1994_10.txt 5KB
3488_7.txt 5KB
3336_7.txt 5KB
3121_10.txt 5KB
6386_10.txt 5KB
7506_7.txt 5KB
552_8.txt 5KB
9031_10.txt 5KB
6217_8.txt 5KB
8668_9.txt 5KB
10526_9.txt 5KB
11005_10.txt 5KB
320_8.txt 5KB
896_10.txt 5KB
8393_8.txt 5KB
3137_8.txt 5KB
8097_7.txt 5KB
3618_7.txt 5KB
591_10.txt 5KB
7513_9.txt 5KB
7213_10.txt 5KB
11723_7.txt 5KB
197_9.txt 5KB
11127_9.txt 5KB
4073_10.txt 4KB
561_10.txt 4KB
7706_7.txt 4KB
12219_10.txt 4KB
4466_8.txt 4KB
8209_8.txt 4KB
4880_9.txt 4KB
12123_8.txt 4KB
1345_9.txt 4KB
5491_10.txt 4KB
6642_10.txt 4KB
1584_9.txt 4KB
589_10.txt 4KB
10618_8.txt 4KB
1354_9.txt 4KB
10231_10.txt 4KB
3112_7.txt 4KB
5074_10.txt 4KB
9956_9.txt 4KB
9222_7.txt 4KB
3373_7.txt 4KB
10761_10.txt 4KB
8023_7.txt 4KB
10463_10.txt 4KB
3941_9.txt 4KB
1503_9.txt 4KB
1495_9.txt 4KB
1762_7.txt 4KB
1041_9.txt 4KB
6539_9.txt 4KB
10409_10.txt 4KB
11625_7.txt 4KB
12234_8.txt 4KB
2897_10.txt 4KB
7164_10.txt 4KB
7514_8.txt 4KB
2013_8.txt 4KB
3695_8.txt 4KB
1830_8.txt 4KB
11536_7.txt 4KB
9037_8.txt 4KB
5911_9.txt 4KB
9652_7.txt 4KB
6748_8.txt 4KB
11432_9.txt 4KB
1761_9.txt 4KB
7215_7.txt 4KB
8129_9.txt 4KB
847_7.txt 4KB
2776_8.txt 4KB
1020_10.txt 4KB
9360_10.txt 4KB
9981_7.txt 3KB
2465_10.txt 3KB
11661_7.txt 3KB
共 2000 条
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 20
资源评论
葡萄籽儿
- 粉丝: 581
- 资源: 2412
上传资源 快速赚钱
- 我的内容管理 展开
- 我的资源 快来上传第一个资源
- 我的收益 登录查看自己的收益
- 我的积分 登录查看自己的积分
- 我的C币 登录后查看C币余额
- 我的收藏
- 我的下载
- 下载帮助
最新资源
资源上传下载、课程学习等过程中有任何疑问或建议,欢迎提出宝贵意见哦~我们会及时处理!
点击此处反馈
安全验证
文档复制为VIP权益,开通VIP直接复制
信息提交成功